Course details
NearGolf score rates overall quality (0–10). USGA rating & slope measure difficulty — how hard the course plays, not how good it is.
What golfers say
People really like the course condition and the food and service at the restaurant. However, the reviews don't really talk about the golf itself, and some comments are about speeding on nearby roads.
Summarized from public reviews — not individual review text.
More golf near Shelter Island Heights
How we score
The NearGolf quality score (0–10) is a weighted blend of reviews, difficulty, price and course pedigree — the same score shown in the app. We label courses we do not have enough signal on as "Not yet rated" rather than guessing.
What the score reflects here: Excellent condition, beautiful views, and challenging layout
Honest data on 11,921 U.S. courses across 51 states — booking info verified, quality scored only where we have real signal.
NearGolf helps you find Gardiner's Bay Country Club and thousands of courses nearby, with honest booking info for each.
Open NearGolf